• HOME
  • ARTICLES
  • COLLABORATIVE PARTNERS
  • INNOVATORS NETWORK
  • TRR ANNUAL FORUM
  • WEBINARS
  • PODCASTS
  • ABOUT
  • RETAIL RADICALS
  • SPEAKING
  • CONTACT US
  • PRIVACY

Mobile Menu

  • ABOUT
  • SIGN UP FOR THE ROBIN REPORT
  • Menu
  • Skip to left header navigation
  • Skip to right header navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary navigation

The Robin Report

Courage

  • ABOUT
  • SIGN UP FOR THE ROBIN REPORT
  • ARTICLES
  • PARTNERS
    • Collaborative Partners
    • Innovators Network
    • Become a Partner of The Robin Report
  • WATCH + LISTEN
    • The Robin Report Podcasts
    • The Robin Report Webcasts
    • 2022 FIT Forum – Mastering the Customer Experience
    • The Robin Report 2022 CEO Forum
    • TRR/Fashion Institute of Technology Series – Pillars of Change
    • TRR/University of Wisconsin Series – The Next Wave of Retail
    • The Robin Report/Syracuse University 2021 CEO Series
    • The Robin Report Annual Forum
    • The Annual Columbia Business School Retail Forum
  • linkedin
  • twitter
  • facebook
  • youtube
  • spotify

What Is Macy’s Thinking?

By Gwen Morrison   |   November 30, 2021

Just as Macy’s announced impressive earnings, which pushed its stock price up 21 percent, a boardroom drama intensified, spurred by an activist investor. The proposal on the table seems astonishing: Split Macy’s multibillion-dollar ecommerce business from its 600-store brick-and-mortar business to release “trapped” shareholder value. This demand was delivered in a letter to the board by Jana Partners after it acquired an unknown stake in the company.

Bifurcated Business

The idea of Macy’s spinning off their ecommerce business shows how investor goals can undermine a retailer’s growth trajectory. Many of today’s successful retail startups praise their investors for patience and autonomy. Privately owned groups look at a range of objectives, including innovation to assess business health. Yet Macy’s investor appears to be pushing for a restructuring that could jeopardize Macy’s near-term and long-term success.

It wasn’t that long ago that Macy’s senior team was almost apologetic for their slow start into ecommerce. Once things started moving along, former CEO, Terry J. Lundgren, boasted at many NRF conferences that their omnichannel strategy was key to future growth.

There was precedent for this maneuver. Earlier this year, privately held Hudson Bay Company split its 40 Saks Fifth Avenue stores from its online unit to form two separate businesses.

In doing so, it sold a $500 million minority equity stake to a private investor, Insight Partners.

The move was controversial, although HBC insisted the Saks brand experience would not change. But how could this be? Every other prominent retailer aims to integrate their online to in-store shopper journey.

Industry thought leaders have long critiqued the organizational siloes that wall off ecommerce teams from their counterpoints running the brick-and-mortar business. Often the online teams and innovation labs are located in separate cities, justified by where top digital talent resides.

Macy’s in the Rear-View Mirror

It wasn’t that long ago that Macy’s senior team was almost apologetic for their slow start into ecommerce. Once things started moving along, former CEO, Terry J. Lundgren, boasted at many NRF conferences that their omnichannel strategy was key to future growth. After overcoming its early inertia, Macy’s has proved to be an innovator on several fronts:

  • Serving shoppers when, where, and how they want to purchase
  • Appealing to younger shoppers who are harder to attract, given today’s myriad of choices
  • Capturing data to personalize offers and enhance loyalty rewards
  • Utilizing physical stores to fulfill online orders, thereby reducing drastic end-of-season markdowns

They also experimented with some engaging technologies that may have been a little too early. Remember Macy’s Backstage Pass with QR codes that brought the Tommy Hilfiger shirt thread count to life? Tests like these may not have been game-changing, but the learnings informed omnichannel strategies.

Haven’t We Seen this Movie Before?

In 2005, hedge fund prodigy Eddie Lampert inserted himself into retail by orchestrating the merger of K-Mart and Sears. Referred to as an “asset stripper,” he claimed real estate holdings, not same-store sales, were the true metric for valuation of the business. Sales continued to fall year after year and the legendary brand filed for bankruptcy in 2018. The last store in Illinois shut its doors a week ago.

Lampert sold off the Sears portfolio one limb at a time, while Amazon redefined the future and continued to innovate new formats such as Amazon Go’s cashless urban convenience stores. What seemed like a novelty just two years ago became an asset in the Covid-19 touchless environment. Amazon is predicated on capturing purchase data wherever their customers go. With more physical stores (such as Amazon Fresh) that compete with traditional formats, they can utilize hyper-local geofencing tools to identify customers entering the parking lot, moving through their store, and checking out. They can also link the in-home experience through voice commerce interactive devices.

The Fork in the Road

As Macy’s works with management consulting firm Alix Partners to assess the ecommerce spinoff proposal, how will they evaluate this new business model? Are they doing what’s best for a handful of large shareholders — or are they positioning the business to serve customers?

By separating the channels, they will certainly have to contemplate a future without the ability to stitch together each contact point of the shopper journey. If Macy’s aim is to truly serve shoppers, personalization, localization and insightful data analytics may have to take a back seat. Honestly, how can this serve customers who are calling the shots and expect to be catered to as the single point of sale, when where and however they want to be served? This approach puts profits before people, which seems the antithesis of Macy’s current slogan: Believe.

Read more on Finance

About Gwen Morrison

Gwen Morrison was CEO for WPP’s Global Retail Practice for 18 years. She is a partner with Candezant Advisory and consults with Retail Tech start-ups. Gwen is a Senior Adviser to the Open Voice Network and co-moderator for their Commerce Community. Gwen has spoken at major industry events including CES,NRF, and Global Retail Forum. She is a contributor to The Robin Report serves on the editorial board of Journal of Brand Strategy.

It’s Midlife Crisis Time for Millennials. Here’s What They’re Buying
Growing Retail C-Suite Vacancies
After the Crash, NFTs Are Repurposed for Retail
Insights for Retail Innovators from Shoptalk
What Ever Happened to Caring About Brand Dilution?
The Culture Power Brand. Designing Brands That Move People.
The Electric Slide
Cautionary Tales of Big Tech and Your Business
Couch Potatoes Unite: The Future of Food Shopping Is Almost Here

It’s Midlife Crisis Time for Millennials. Here’s What They’re Buying

Growing Retail C-Suite Vacancies

After the Crash, NFTs Are Repurposed for Retail

Insights for Retail Innovators from Shoptalk

What Ever Happened to Caring About Brand Dilution?

The Culture Power Brand. Designing Brands That Move People.

The Electric Slide

Cautionary Tales of Big Tech and Your Business

Couch Potatoes Unite: The Future of Food Shopping Is Almost Here

CONNECT WITH TRR

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • HOME
  • ABOUT
  • BROADCASTS
  • CONTACT US
  • SPEAKING
  • RETAIL RADICALS
  • PRIVACY
  • Account

Copyright © 2023 · Robin Lewis, Inc. All rights reserved. Copying or reproducing, by any means whatsoever, of The Robin Report, or any distribution hereof, in whole or in part, without the express written consent of Robin Lewis, Inc. is strictly prohibited. The Robin Report is published for senior executives in the retail, fashion, beauty, consumer products and related industries. The opinions expressed herein are not, and should not be construed as investment or other advice. All expressions of opinion are subject to change without notice.

GET GREAT CONTENT
DIRECTLY INTO YOUR INBOX